Maudie was married three times. Her first marriage was in 1941 to Charles Fillmore Prickett II (1901–1954), co-founder and general manager of the Pasadena Playhouse, with whom she had two chlldren: Charles Fillmore Prickett III (1949–2006), who became an orthopedic surgeon, and a daughter, Charie Doyle Prickett, (1950- ). In 1961, seven years after the death of her first husband, she married Dr. Eakle W. Cartwright, a physician, who unfortunately died the following year. Maudie's final marriage was to Cyril Bernard Cooper (1900–1971), mayor of Pasadena. He too predeceased her.