Having begun dating in February 2012, Conrad and law student and former Something Corporate Guitarist William Tell, moved into a shared residence in Westwood, Los Angeles in September 2013, and announced their engagement the following month. That October, Conrad and her friend Hannah Skvarla opened the online store The Little Market, which distributes handmade pieces from women of varying cultural backgrounds. Conrad and Tell got married on September 13, 2014 in California. On January 1, 2017, Conrad announced via instagram that she and Tell were expecting their first child. Their son, william "Liam" James Tell, was born on July 5, 2017.